Asia Associated Press By TIM SULLIVAN Christianity Crime General news India International Latin America and Caribbean News Prayer Religion Religious issues Religious scandals Roman Catholicism Sexual abuse Sexual assault Social affairs Social issues South America South Asia Violent crime

AP finds long history of nuns abused by priests in India

Associated Press Photo

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

Associated Press Photo

On this Sunday, Nov. four, 2018, photograph, a nun partakes in the sacrament of confession on the Immaculate Coronary heart of Mary Cathedral in Kottayam in the southern Indian state of Kerala. An AP investigation has uncovered a decades-long history of nuns in India enduring sexual abuse from inside the Catholic church. (AP Photograph/Manish Swarup)

KURAVILANGAD, India (AP) — The tales spill out in the sitting rooms of Catholic convents, the place portraits of Jesus hold watch and followers spin quietly overhead. They spill out in church assembly halls bathed in fluorescent lights, and over cups of low cost on the spot espresso in convent kitchens. All the time, the tales come haltingly, quietly. Typically, the nuns converse at little greater than a whisper.

Throughout India, the nuns speak of priests who pushed into their bedrooms and of priests who pressured them to show shut friendships into intercourse. They speak about being groped and kissed, of palms pressed towards them by males they have been raised to consider have been representatives of Jesus Christ.

“He was drunk,” stated one nun, starting her story. “You don’t know how to say no,” stated one other.

At its most grim, the nuns converse of repeated rapes, and of a Catholic hierarchy that did little to guard them.

The Vatican has long been conscious of nuns sexually abused by priests and bishops in Asia, Europe, South America and Africa, nevertheless it has executed little or no to cease it, The Related Press reported final yr.

Now, the AP has investigated the state of affairs in a single nation — India — and uncovered a decades-long history of nuns enduring sexual abuse from inside the church. Nuns described in element the sexual strain they endured from priests, and almost two dozen different individuals — nuns, former nuns and priests, and others — stated that they had direct information of such incidents.

Nonetheless, the size of the issue in India stays unclear, cloaked by a strong tradition of silence. Many nuns consider abuse is commonplace, insisting most sisters can a minimum of inform of keeping off a priest’s sexual advances. Some consider it’s uncommon. Virtually none, although, speak about it readily, and most converse solely on the situation they not be recognized.

However this summer time, one Indian nun pressured the difficulty into the open.

When repeated complaints to church officers introduced no response, the 44-year-old nun filed a police grievance towards the bishop who oversees her spiritual order, accusing him of raping her 13 occasions over two years. Quickly after, a gaggle of her fellow nuns launched a two-week public protest in India’s Catholic heartland, demanding the bishop’s arrest.

It was an unprecedented motion, dividing India’s Catholic group. Contained in the accuser’s convent in rural Kerala state, she and the nuns who help her at the moment are pariahs, remoted from the opposite sisters, many of whom insist the bishop is harmless. The protesting nuns get hate mail and keep away from going out.

“Some people are accusing us of working against the church, of being against the church. They say, ‘You are worshipping Satan,’” stated one supporter, Sister Josephine Villoonnickal. “But we need to stand up for the truth.”

Villoonnickal has been a nun for 23 years, becoming a member of when she was an adolescent. She scoffs at the concept she needs to hurt the church.

“We want to die as sisters,” she stated.


Some nuns’ accounts date again many years — like that of the sister, barely out of her teenagers, who was educating in a Catholic faculty in the early 1990s.

It was exhausting work, and she or he was wanting ahead to the prospect to mirror on what had led her — fortunately — to convent life.

“We have kind of a retreat before we renew our vows,” she stated, sitting in the painfully neat sitting room of her big-city convent, the place doilies cowl most each floor, chairs are lined up in rows and the blare of horns drifts in via open home windows. “We take one week off and we go for prayers and silence.”

She had traveled to a New Delhi retreat middle, a set of concrete buildings the place she gathered with different younger nuns. A priest was there to steer the sisters in reflection.

The nun, who like others interviewed for this story spoke on situation she not be recognized, is a robust and forceful lady who has spent years working with India’s poor and dispossessed, from battered wives to evicted households.

However when she talks concerning the retreat her voice grows quiet, as if she’s afraid to be overheard in the empty room: “I felt this person, maybe he had some thoughts, some attraction.”

He was in his 60s. She was 4 many years youthful.

One night time, the priest went to a neighborhood social gathering. He got here again late, after 9:30 p.m., and knocked at her room.

“‘I need to meet you,’” he stated when she cracked open the door, insisting he needed to debate her religious life. She might odor the alcohol.

“You’re not stable. I’m not ready to meet you,” she advised him.

However the priest pressured open the door. He tried to kiss her. He grabbed at her physique, groping wherever he might.

Weeping, she pushed him again sufficient to slam the door and lock it.

It wasn’t rape. She is aware of it might have been a lot worse. However many years later she nonetheless reels on the reminiscence, and this robust lady, for a number of moments, seems like a scared younger woman: “It was such a terrifying experience.”

Afterward she quietly informed her mom superior, who allowed her to keep away from different conferences with the priest. She additionally wrote an nameless letter to church officers, which she thinks might have led to the priest being re-assigned.

However nothing was stated aloud. There have been no public reprimands, no warnings to the various nuns the priest would work with via his long profession.

She was too afraid to problem him brazenly.

“I couldn’t imagine taking that stand. It was too scary,” she stated. “For me it was risking my own vocation.”

So the fierce nun remained silent.


Catholic history is crammed with ladies who turned martyrs to their very own purity: Saint Agatha had her breasts torn off for refusing to marry; Saint Lucy was burned alive and stabbed in the throat for defending her virginity; Saint Maria Goretti was 11 years previous when she was killed by a person who tried to rape her.

“It is a sin!” Maria is claimed to have cried out. “God does not want it!”

However for a nun, preventing off a priest’s advances means pinballing by way of centuries-old sexual and clerical traditions. Celibacy is a cornerstone of Catholic spiritual life, as is sexual purity amongst nuns. Many nuns say a sister who admits to a sexual expertise — even when it’s pressured — faces the danger of isolation inside her order, and probably even expulsion.

“You’re not sure if you’ll be kept in your congregation, because so much is about your vow of chastity,” stated Sister Shalini Mulackal, a New Delhi-based theologian. “That fear is there for the young ones to disclose what has happened to them.”

On the similar time, priests are seen as dwelling representatives of Christ, with obedience to them one other Catholic cornerstone.

Then there’s the isolation of younger ladies struggling to seek out their method in new communities after leaving their houses.

Caught at this intersection of sexual taboo, Catholic hierarchy and loneliness, sisters might be left on the mercy of predatory priests.

“There’s a lot of emotion bottled up and when a little tenderness is shown by somebody it can be so easy for you to cross boundaries,” stated Sister Dorothy Fernandes, who has spent years working with the city poor in japanese India. “It can be hard to tell what is love and what is exploitation.”

It’s notably arduous for sisters from Kerala, a deeply conservative area long the birthplace of most Indian nuns. Intercourse is never talked about brazenly in small-town Kerala, girls and boys are largely stored aside, and a visual bra strap could be a minor disaster for a younger lady.

“Once you grow up, once you get your first menstruation, you are not encouraged to speak normally to a boy. And the boys also vice-versa,” stated a nun from Kerala, a cheerful lady with sparkly glass earrings and a straightforward smile. She remembers the distress of Sunday mass as an adolescent, when boys would stand outdoors the church to observe women submitting in, eyes crawling over their younger figures. “We have a terrible taboo about sex.”

That naivety, she stated, may be pricey.

Just like the time she was a novice nun, nonetheless in her teenagers, and an older priest got here to the Catholic middle the place she labored. He was from Goa, a coastal area and former Portuguese colony.

She shook her head: “I was in charge of visitors, and we had this bad habit of being hospitable.”

At one level, she introduced the priest’s laundry to his small room, the place he was sitting. As she set down the garments, he grabbed her and commenced to kiss her.

At first, she had no concept what was occurring.

“The kissing was all coming here,” she stated, gesturing at her chest.

The confusion of that day continues to be clear on her face: “I was young. He was from Goa. I am from Kerala. In my mind I was trying to figure out: ‘Is this the way that Goans kiss?’”

She shortly understood what was occurring however couldn’t escape his fierce grip. She additionally couldn’t name out for assist: “I cannot shout! He’s a priest.”

“I didn’t want to offend him. I didn’t want to make him feel bad,” she stated.

So she pushed herself away from him till she might slip out the door.

She quietly informed a senior nun to not ship novices to the priest’s room. However, just like the nun who fought the drunken priest, she made no official grievance.

A grievance towards a priest means leveling an accusation towards somebody larger in the church hierarchy. It could possibly imply getting pulled right into a tangle of malicious rumors and church politics. It means risking your fame, and the status of your order.

Within the church, even some of those that doubt there’s widespread abuse of nuns say the silence might be enveloping.

Archbishop Kuriakose Bharanikulangara, a New Delhi-based church chief, calls incidents of abuse “kind of sporadic. Once here, once there.”

However “many people don’t want to talk,” he continued. “They may talk in the community, but they don’t want to bring it to the public, to the court.”

Talking up may also danger monetary troubles, since many congregations of nuns are financially subservient to priests and bishops.

The silence is magnified in India by demographics, spiritual politics and a deep-seated perception that ladies have little worth.

There are roughly 18 million Catholics in India, however that’s a small minority in this largely Hindu nation of 1.three billion. Talking up might tarnish the picture of their church, many nuns fear, and feed criticism by Hindu hardliners.

“Even we, as religious sisters, even we try to keep it quiet,” stated Mulackal, the theologian. “A woman who goes through this experience, she just wants to hide it and pretend everything is OK.”


The rapes, the nun says, occurred in Room 20 of a small convent on the finish of a one-lane street in rural Kerala.

Set amid rows of banana and rubber timber close to the little city of Kuravilangad, the sisters on the St. Francis Mission Residence spend their days in prayer or caring for the aged. Within the backyard, a statue of the Virgin Mary overlooks an ornamental fish pond the dimensions of a toddler’s wading pool. The pond is roofed in inexperienced scum.

The rapist, she says, was probably the most highly effective man in this tiny small world: Bishop Franco Mulakkal.

Sensible and impressive, Mulakkal had risen from small-town Kerala to grow to be a bishop in north India, overseeing a sprawling Catholic group. He was additionally the official patron of her group of 81 sisters, the Missionaries of Jesus, wielding immense affect over its budgets and job assignments.

The nun is a pleasant lady with jet black hair recognized for her quiet confidence. Each few months, she says, Mulakkal would go to the St. Francis convent and summon her. Then, in response to a letter she wrote to church officers, he raped her.

The letter says the primary rape occurred on Might 5, 2014. The final time was Sept. 23, 2016. The dates are recorded in the convent’s customer logs.

Mulakkal angrily denies the accusations, telling reporters the fees have been “baseless and concocted” and accusing the sister of making an attempt to blackmail him into giving her a greater job.

“I am going through painful agony,” stated Mulakkal, who was jailed for 3 weeks and launched on bail in October. “I tell everyone to pray to God: Let the truth prevail.”

Catholicism envelopes this half of Kerala. Cities are marked by their cathedrals, convents and roadside shrines, the place the Virgin watches passing visitors or St. George slays the dragon. Companies proclaim their house owners’ religion: St. Mary’s Furnishings and Mattress Middle; Ave Maria Electronics; Jesus Oil Industries.

Round right here, many see Mulakkal as a martyr.

A string of supporters visited him in jail, and crowds greeted him when he returned residence, a hoop of policemen holding again individuals who showered him with flower petals. “Hearty Welcome!” a banner proclaimed.

However on the St. Francis convent, one group of nuns watched information stories about that welcome with dismay. Whereas the sister leveling the accusations towards Mulakkal doesn’t converse publicly, a half-dozen nuns cluster round her, providing help and talking on her behalf.

“Nobody came to see sister, but so many people came to wait in line to meet Bishop Franco in jail,” stated Villoonnickal, the nun, who moved again to Kerala to help the lady she calls “our survivor sister.”

That sister was the second of 5 youngsters in a Kerala household. Her father was in the military. Her mom died when she was in highschool. Wracked with grief, she was despatched to stick with a cousin – a priest – dwelling in north India. Impressed by her time with him, she turned a nun in 1994, working in her early years as a instructor.

She knew Mulakkal, of course. Everybody in the Missionaries of Jesus is aware of him. However the two have been by no means shut, the accuser’s associates say, and had no consensual sexual relationship.

It was about worry.

“The bishop is such a powerful person and standing against him, where will she go?” requested Villoonnickal. “If she went home what will happen to her?”

“Many times she was telling him to stop. But each time he was forcing himself on her,” she continued.

Ultimately, they are saying, she advised some sisters what was occurring. Then she says she repeatedly complained to church authorities. When nothing occurred, she went to the police.

She additionally went to confession.

There, in accordance with the opposite nuns, she was advised she had to withstand the bishop.

“‘Even if you have to die, don’t submit yourself.’” the priest advised her in confession, based on Villoonnickal. “‘Be courageous.’”

Catholic authorities have stated little concerning the case, with India’s Catholic Bishops’ Convention saying in an October assertion that it has no jurisdiction over particular person bishops, and that the investigation and courtroom case, which might take a few years, should run their course.

“Silence should in no way be construed as siding with either of the two parties,” the group stated. “We request prayers for the Church at this difficult time.”


In Malayalam, the language of Kerala, sisters who depart the convent are typically marked as “Madhilu Chadi” — Wall Jumpers. It’s a mocking time period for the sexually annoyed and is usually used for nuns and priests who’ve fled spiritual life.

Those that keep get respect. They’ve communities that embrace them. Their lives have path, objective. Those that depart typically discover themselves adrift in India, looking for new identities and spurned by households and pals. The occasions that knit households collectively — weddings, funerals, reunions — are out of the blue off-limits. The emotional toll might be immense.

Talking up concerning the church’s troubles, many nuns say, might finish with them pressured from their convents, minimize off in some ways from what they’ve all the time recognized.

“It’s a fear of being isolated if I speak the truth,” stated the nun who fought off the drunken priest. “If you do that, you have to go against your own community, your own religious superiors.”

The result’s an engulfing silence. Silence is the armor that sisters use to guard themselves and the lives they’ve created, even when it additionally means battling their reminiscences, and defending the lads who abused them.

In the long run, most say nothing.

“I didn’t tell anybody,” stated the nun who escaped the priest kissing her chest, and who waited a few years to speak about what had occurred to her. “So you understand how these things are covered up.”